• Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Editorial Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Web Stories
Friday, July 11, 2025
London Journal | The Voice of London
  • Home
  • Politics
    Charles warns small boats crisis is a ‘profound challenge’ as he hosts Macron at state banquet ahead of migrant ‘deal’

    Charles warns small boats crisis is a ‘profound challenge’ as he hosts Macron at state banquet ahead of migrant ‘deal’

    Jeremy Corbyn’s planned hard-left party of two in chaos as he refuses to confirm who’ll lead it

    Jeremy Corbyn’s planned hard-left party of two in chaos as he refuses to confirm who’ll lead it

    Keir insists he’s still backing Reeves after ‘late-night talks’ as he tries to steady ship after Commons chaos

    Keir insists he’s still backing Reeves after ‘late-night talks’ as he tries to steady ship after Commons chaos

    Critics have slammed Ed Miliband’s net zero policies after major UK oil refinery went bust

    Critics have slammed Ed Miliband’s net zero policies after major UK oil refinery went bust

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Digital Marketing
      • Real Estate
      Future of Media Awards shortlist highlights best of digital journalism in 2025

      Future of Media Awards shortlist highlights best of digital journalism in 2025

      Business Post: From ‘shocking’ engagement to 12,000 subscribers

      Business Post: From ‘shocking’ engagement to 12,000 subscribers

      News diary 7-13 July: 7/7 bombings 20th anniversary, Netanyahu at White House, Macron state visit to UK

      Urgent bid lodged with UK regulator to stop Google AI Overviews ‘stealing journalism’

      Urgent bid lodged with UK regulator to stop Google AI Overviews ‘stealing journalism’

      Trending Tags

      • Tech
        ‘Death date’ of universe revealed as scientists predict when ‘shrinking’ will start before ‘Big Crunch’ wipes us all out

        ‘Death date’ of universe revealed as scientists predict when ‘shrinking’ will start before ‘Big Crunch’ wipes us all out

        Is this the breakfast of the future? Bread made of BUGS & fungus created to fight food shortage – so would YOU try it?

        Is this the breakfast of the future? Bread made of BUGS & fungus created to fight food shortage – so would YOU try it?

        Mystery of Captain Cook’s lost ship is SOLVED after 250 years as scientists discover sunken remains of HMS Endeavour

        Mystery of Captain Cook’s lost ship is SOLVED after 250 years as scientists discover sunken remains of HMS Endeavour

        Sex-crazed insects cause car to flip with drivers warned to keep windows closed on roads as the bugs invade US

        Sex-crazed insects cause car to flip with drivers warned to keep windows closed on roads as the bugs invade US

        I used ChatGPT as FREE nutritionist to rate my diet & turbocharge my health – it found TWO hidden dangers in my meals

        I used ChatGPT as FREE nutritionist to rate my diet & turbocharge my health – it found TWO hidden dangers in my meals

        Huge number of horses’ facial expressions revealed as scientists discover equine ‘language’

        Huge number of horses’ facial expressions revealed as scientists discover equine ‘language’

      • Health
      • Science

        We’ve probably already been discovered by aliens, but they have some pretty good reasons to hide.

        Almost everyone is said to benefit from a scientifically supported method for improving sleep.

        2,500-year-old rock engravings were found near Mosul, Iraq.

        Is the soul of a person eternal? the findings of scientists

        With its most recent move, is General Electric abandoning wind power?

      • Crypto
      • Entertainment
        • All
        • Gaming
        • Sports
        Jon Jones performs retirement U-turn and announces return to UFC testing pool after Dana White lying claims

        Jon Jones performs retirement U-turn and announces return to UFC testing pool after Dana White lying claims

        Tyson Fury heads off to business meeting still wearing Primark Soccer Aid suit after dropping F-bomb live on ITV

        Tyson Fury heads off to business meeting still wearing Primark Soccer Aid suit after dropping F-bomb live on ITV

        ‘This’ll wind people up’ – DeChambeau and Rose’s response to how club golfers would cope at Oakmont US Open course

        ‘This’ll wind people up’ – DeChambeau and Rose’s response to how club golfers would cope at Oakmont US Open course

        UFC 316 – Merab Dvalishvili vs Sean O’Malley 2: Fight time, full card, TV channel and live stream ahead of huge rematch

        UFC 316 – Merab Dvalishvili vs Sean O’Malley 2: Fight time, full card, TV channel and live stream ahead of huge rematch

        Olympics gender row boxer Imane Khelif BANNED from next week’s World Cup as chiefs introduce mandatory sex testing

        Olympics gender row boxer Imane Khelif BANNED from next week’s World Cup as chiefs introduce mandatory sex testing

      • Lifestyle
        • All
        • Fashion
        • food
        • Home improvement
        • Travel
        A Site for Situated Practices: Mezzanine

        Exhibition: Substance & Recoding: The Narrative of Contemporary Objects in the Semantic Turn

        Discover Amsterdam’s beauty from the water

        An adventure on the canals of Amsterdam

        An adventure on the canals of Amsterdam

        Eromosele Gideon Eigbiremolen Unveils Sustainable Vision for SS24 with Burvain's Latest Collection.

        Eromosele Gideon Eigbiremolen Unveils Sustainable Vision for SS24 with Burvain’s Latest Collection.

        after builders cleaning

        After Builders Cleaning Services in UK with Cliffycox: Reviving Spaces, Redefining Cleanliness

        Creating an Oasis Deponti Glass Room Products and Maze Outdoor Kitchens

        Creating an Oasis: Deponti Glass Room Products and Maze Outdoor Kitchens

      • Travel
      • Real Estate
      • Sports
      • More
        • Press Release
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Politics
        Charles warns small boats crisis is a ‘profound challenge’ as he hosts Macron at state banquet ahead of migrant ‘deal’

        Charles warns small boats crisis is a ‘profound challenge’ as he hosts Macron at state banquet ahead of migrant ‘deal’

        Jeremy Corbyn’s planned hard-left party of two in chaos as he refuses to confirm who’ll lead it

        Jeremy Corbyn’s planned hard-left party of two in chaos as he refuses to confirm who’ll lead it

        Keir insists he’s still backing Reeves after ‘late-night talks’ as he tries to steady ship after Commons chaos

        Keir insists he’s still backing Reeves after ‘late-night talks’ as he tries to steady ship after Commons chaos

        Critics have slammed Ed Miliband’s net zero policies after major UK oil refinery went bust

        Critics have slammed Ed Miliband’s net zero policies after major UK oil refinery went bust

        Trending Tags

        • Business
          • All
          • Digital Marketing
          • Real Estate
          Future of Media Awards shortlist highlights best of digital journalism in 2025

          Future of Media Awards shortlist highlights best of digital journalism in 2025

          Business Post: From ‘shocking’ engagement to 12,000 subscribers

          Business Post: From ‘shocking’ engagement to 12,000 subscribers

          News diary 7-13 July: 7/7 bombings 20th anniversary, Netanyahu at White House, Macron state visit to UK

          Urgent bid lodged with UK regulator to stop Google AI Overviews ‘stealing journalism’

          Urgent bid lodged with UK regulator to stop Google AI Overviews ‘stealing journalism’

          Trending Tags

          • Tech
            ‘Death date’ of universe revealed as scientists predict when ‘shrinking’ will start before ‘Big Crunch’ wipes us all out

            ‘Death date’ of universe revealed as scientists predict when ‘shrinking’ will start before ‘Big Crunch’ wipes us all out

            Is this the breakfast of the future? Bread made of BUGS & fungus created to fight food shortage – so would YOU try it?

            Is this the breakfast of the future? Bread made of BUGS & fungus created to fight food shortage – so would YOU try it?

            Mystery of Captain Cook’s lost ship is SOLVED after 250 years as scientists discover sunken remains of HMS Endeavour

            Mystery of Captain Cook’s lost ship is SOLVED after 250 years as scientists discover sunken remains of HMS Endeavour

            Sex-crazed insects cause car to flip with drivers warned to keep windows closed on roads as the bugs invade US

            Sex-crazed insects cause car to flip with drivers warned to keep windows closed on roads as the bugs invade US

            I used ChatGPT as FREE nutritionist to rate my diet & turbocharge my health – it found TWO hidden dangers in my meals

            I used ChatGPT as FREE nutritionist to rate my diet & turbocharge my health – it found TWO hidden dangers in my meals

            Huge number of horses’ facial expressions revealed as scientists discover equine ‘language’

            Huge number of horses’ facial expressions revealed as scientists discover equine ‘language’

          • Health
          • Science

            We’ve probably already been discovered by aliens, but they have some pretty good reasons to hide.

            Almost everyone is said to benefit from a scientifically supported method for improving sleep.

            2,500-year-old rock engravings were found near Mosul, Iraq.

            Is the soul of a person eternal? the findings of scientists

            With its most recent move, is General Electric abandoning wind power?

          • Crypto
          • Entertainment
            • All
            • Gaming
            • Sports
            Jon Jones performs retirement U-turn and announces return to UFC testing pool after Dana White lying claims

            Jon Jones performs retirement U-turn and announces return to UFC testing pool after Dana White lying claims

            Tyson Fury heads off to business meeting still wearing Primark Soccer Aid suit after dropping F-bomb live on ITV

            Tyson Fury heads off to business meeting still wearing Primark Soccer Aid suit after dropping F-bomb live on ITV

            ‘This’ll wind people up’ – DeChambeau and Rose’s response to how club golfers would cope at Oakmont US Open course

            ‘This’ll wind people up’ – DeChambeau and Rose’s response to how club golfers would cope at Oakmont US Open course

            UFC 316 – Merab Dvalishvili vs Sean O’Malley 2: Fight time, full card, TV channel and live stream ahead of huge rematch

            UFC 316 – Merab Dvalishvili vs Sean O’Malley 2: Fight time, full card, TV channel and live stream ahead of huge rematch

            Olympics gender row boxer Imane Khelif BANNED from next week’s World Cup as chiefs introduce mandatory sex testing

            Olympics gender row boxer Imane Khelif BANNED from next week’s World Cup as chiefs introduce mandatory sex testing

          • Lifestyle
            • All
            • Fashion
            • food
            • Home improvement
            • Travel
            A Site for Situated Practices: Mezzanine

            Exhibition: Substance & Recoding: The Narrative of Contemporary Objects in the Semantic Turn

            Discover Amsterdam’s beauty from the water

            An adventure on the canals of Amsterdam

            An adventure on the canals of Amsterdam

            Eromosele Gideon Eigbiremolen Unveils Sustainable Vision for SS24 with Burvain's Latest Collection.

            Eromosele Gideon Eigbiremolen Unveils Sustainable Vision for SS24 with Burvain’s Latest Collection.

            after builders cleaning

            After Builders Cleaning Services in UK with Cliffycox: Reviving Spaces, Redefining Cleanliness

            Creating an Oasis Deponti Glass Room Products and Maze Outdoor Kitchens

            Creating an Oasis: Deponti Glass Room Products and Maze Outdoor Kitchens

          • Travel
          • Real Estate
          • Sports
          • More
            • Press Release
          No Result
          View All Result
          London Journal | The Voice of London
          No Result
          View All Result

          Lesson learned for SAP implementation of engineer-to-order manufacturing solution

          by Amina
          November 25, 2023
          in Press Release
          0
          SHARES
          Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedin

          I was a core team member for a large SAP S/4 HANA implementation in Europe’s large HVAC manufacturing company. My name is Tim Anderson, and I have over 30+ years of manufacturing experience. This was my first experience with SAP.

          This article aims to share my mixed feelings about SAP’s solution and make others aware of its limitations and standard out-of-the-box solutions. Things might have changed now, but this is based on implementation in 2021-22.

          What is ETO for us technically?

          Any unique customer requirements when received if the SAP system cannot derive BOM components and routing operations/steps automatically either to 0 % or less than 10%. This means the System could derive only 10% or less of BOM component /Routing steps. This means 90% + design and hence heavily engineer dependent.

          What are the key challenges in ETO?

          It is very well recorded in Manufacturing Projects – SAP Engineer to Order (ETO) – Noveco (novecosystems.com)

          • Preliminary engineering and design
          • Cost estimation, tendering, and customer quotation
          • Detailed concurrent engineering and design based on customer requirements
          • Material requirements planning
          • Resource and capacity planning and load balancing
          • Procurement of sub-contracted services and materials
          • Advance procurement of long lead items
          • Production scheduling in relation to completion of engineering tasks and available capacities
          • Production order execution coordinated by project dates and quantity requirements
          • Forecasting of final estimated cost at completion, profits and revenues
          • Engineering change management and project variations and issue management
          • Customer billing
          • Profit recognition
          • Monthly reporting of project KPIs, progress, variations and issues

          In ETO manufacturing, the quotation process must be based on cost estimation of the complex product structures, including engineering costs, costs of standard components and components to be designed and engineered, risks and contingencies, price escalations, etc. The cost estimation must be produced before MRP, and production orders are created and must be used as a basis for project budgets and revenue plan.

          While customer-specific manufacturing is taking place, the large portions of work on the shop floor are usually associated with the manufacturing of standard components and assemblies that have no specific customer requirements.

          Every ETO process usually includes make-to-order (MTO) and even make-to-stock (MTS). The degree between ETO, MTO, and MTS varies in different industries and companies.

          Production orders of assemblies and sub-assemblies are scheduled and executed in coordination with project activities, which feed required quantity and completion dates down to the production order management system.

          The completed project’s final cost includes cost of engineering and design, as well as production variances associated with the production of customer-specific production orders (ETO and MTO).

          What does SAP suggest as best practice for ETO?

          There are many topics related to ETO on help.sap.com. We found the following process flow closer to our requirements. We used Proman as suggested, and it is very useful.

          Lesson learned for SAP implementation of engineer-to-order manufacturing solution

          What was our solution?

          The high-level process flow we adopted is as follows:

          Lesson learned for SAP implementation of engineer-to-order manufacturing solution

          What did we like in SAP as out-of-box?

          • BOM transfer functionality. In ETO, BOMs are released in various versions, and SAP has great functionality to transfer full/delta BOM to the project structure.
          • Actual cost functionality. In SAP, you have the functionality to track Actual costs. Before manufacturing starts, Engineers book their time using the timesheet Fiori app linked to project WBS. Thus, you will get actual costs at various stages of the project (Usually long-running)
          • Result Analysis (RA): Great feature to track and realize long-running projects.
          • Great integration with sales, project systems, production, procurement, quality modules, and finance.
          • Promon for procurement control and monitoring
          • Long lead item planning
          • Order change process.

          What did we not like in SAP for ETO?

          • Promising date calculation to customer. : Since the ETO product is not ready during the sales order stage, it is difficult to give a precise delivery date to the customer.
            1. We used project network templates with each ETO product (VC model), and the project end date was used as the promised delivery date.
            2. Sales order BOM, when edited, is not getting considered for later MRP runs – We did implement an SAP note and an enhancement
            3. SAP was dynamically producing new routing based on VC chars and was not considered for MRP. This was also handled through a note and enhancements.
            4. Not able to forecast planned cost in the beginning of the project since BOM/routing is not ready.Used Network/previous similar wbs and enhancement for planned cost calculation. In standard, the planned cost is auto-calculated based on project WBS cost until release.

          What are the best resources on the internet to refer to SAP ETO solution?

          • SAP best practices. SAP gives a lot of options. Hence, you may have to find your own solution based on these best practices.
          • Found a research gate PDF very useful. Author Narasimha explains the solution clearly based on your landscape, license, and budget. We also found this very useful for our solution and adopted it. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/360781494_Engineer_to_Order_Approaches_in_SAP
          • com /https:softengine.com/ www.fujitsu.com if you want to have a custom solution do go through these sites.

           

          Recent News

          Future of Media Awards shortlist highlights best of digital journalism in 2025

          Future of Media Awards shortlist highlights best of digital journalism in 2025

          July 10, 2025
          The Morbi bridge disaster would have survived 13 human life if the work done in the High Court, only on paper, if work was done.

          The Morbi bridge disaster would have survived 13 human life if the work done in the High Court, only on paper, if work was done.

          July 9, 2025
          10 Indian players scoring centuries in Lords, Sachin-Kohli could not overcome 100 figures

          10 Indian players scoring centuries in Lords, Sachin-Kohli could not overcome 100 figures

          July 9, 2025
          Whatever the war, these 10 countries will never be attacked by a nuclear missile…! Learn

          Whatever the war, these 10 countries will never be attacked by a nuclear missile…! Learn

          July 9, 2025
          Stock Market: 338% return and now a large order of Rs 15.84 crore, the stock will be on Thursday ‘Hot Favorite’

          Stock Market: 338% return and now a large order of Rs 15.84 crore, the stock will be on Thursday ‘Hot Favorite’

          July 9, 2025
          Ferry passengers stranded at UK port for over 10 HOURS due to ‘murder’ arrest

          Ferry passengers stranded at UK port for over 10 HOURS due to ‘murder’ arrest

          July 9, 2025
          Charles warns small boats crisis is a ‘profound challenge’ as he hosts Macron at state banquet ahead of migrant ‘deal’

          Charles warns small boats crisis is a ‘profound challenge’ as he hosts Macron at state banquet ahead of migrant ‘deal’

          July 9, 2025
          • Home
          • Privacy Policy
          • Editorial Policy
          • About Us
          • Contribute
          • Advertise with us
          • Contact Us

          All Rights Reserved © 2022 London Journal - Voice of London

          No Result
          View All Result
          • Home
          • Politics
          • World
          • Business
          • Science
          • Crypto
          • Entertainment
          • Gaming
          • Opinion
          • Sports
          • Fashion
          • Lifestyle
          • Travel
          • Tech
          • Health
          • Food

          All Rights Reserved © 2022 London Journal - Voice of London