A long-awaited review of youth unemployment, due on Tuesday, will call for lower employer National Insurance on workers aged 21 to 24, phased in over five years and starting with shops, bars and restaurants, alongside a tougher line on benefits for under-25s.
Employers could pay less tax for taking on young staff under proposals in a major independent review of youth worklessness led by the former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn. According to the BBC, the report will recommend that employer National Insurance (NI) on workers aged 21 to 24 is gradually reduced over a five-year period, with retail and hospitality first in line.
The centrepiece of the tax proposal is to double the earnings threshold at which firms start paying NI on staff in that age band, from £5,000 to £10,000. Milburn will attach a significant caveat, however: the change should only happen “when fiscal conditions allow”.
The review, a year in the making, is due to be published on Tuesday. It lands as the government tries to bring down the number of young people who are not in employment, education or training, commonly referred to as Neets.
A tax cut, but not yet
Milburn is expected to argue that slashing employer NI across the board straight away would not be a sensible use of several billion pounds of public money given the state of the nation’s finances. The left-leaning Resolution Foundation has estimated that scrapping NI immediately for 21 to 24-year-olds would cost £5.1bn, the BBC reported.
Starting with shops, bars and restaurants reflects where young people actually work. Retail and hospitality between them account for 37% of jobs held by 16 to 24-year-olds.
The report will also say that the rise in employer NI introduced under Sir Keir Starmer’s government did not cause the Neet problem. That is unlikely to settle the argument. Business groups have blamed the higher rate for slower hiring, and the Conservatives say they would halve employer NI costs. The shadow work and pensions secretary, Helen Whately, told the BBC the government should “just stop doing the taxing”.
Some small employers say the pressure is already acute. Collette Osborne, who runs three hair salons in Nottingham, told the BBC she once took on eight apprentices a year but can no longer afford any, and that her workforce has more than halved to 21. “I feel like the government’s foot is firmly on my neck,” she said.
Benefits overhaul and a jobs guarantee
The NI proposal is only one part of a wider package. Milburn will also recommend that under-25s should no longer be able to claim the health element of Universal Credit or personal independence payment (Pip), receiving instead a new youth allowance paid at the standard Universal Credit rate, the Independent reported. In return, the state would take on a legal duty to guarantee young people a job, training or employment support, with benefits at risk for those who turn it down.
Milburn has put the annual cost of supporting economically inactive young people at £22bn. Official figures cited by Reuters show 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 were Neet in the second quarter of this year, about 13% of the age group. The UK’s youth unemployment rate of 15.6% compares with 3.4% for older workers, a far wider gap than is typical elsewhere in Europe.
Ministers moved ahead of the review. The Department for Work and Pensions announced on Saturday that its Jobs Guarantee, which fully funds up to 25 hours a week of paid work for six months at the relevant minimum wage, will be available across England, Scotland and Wales from the end of November. From April 2027, 18 to 24-year-olds on Universal Credit will qualify after 12 months out of work rather than 18. The department says the scheme will help more than 90,000 young people into work by March 2029.
What it means for London and UK readers
For London’s large hospitality and retail sector, a phased NI cut aimed first at shops, bars and restaurants would be directly felt in wage bills, though the “fiscal conditions” caveat means no business should plan around it yet. The capital’s employers also gain access to the Jobs Guarantee for the first time: the pilot ran in six areas, including Greater Manchester, Birmingham and Solihull, and the East Midlands, but not London.
For young people and their families, the trade-off is sharper. Support would become more conditional, and those currently relying on health-related benefits could receive less.
What happens next
The full report is published on Tuesday. The government has not committed to accepting every recommendation and is expected to respond in the coming weeks. Any NI change would need Treasury backing, while benefit cuts are likely to face resistance from Labour MPs who have previously rebelled over welfare reform. Milburn himself describes the task as a 10-year programme.



























