
Ministers weighing a cut to Britain’s electric car sales targets are under growing pressure to hold their nerve, with campaigners, fleet operators and drivers’ groups warning that weakening the ZEV mandate would slow the switch to cheaper motoring just as the government’s own climate advisers prepare to have their say.
Update, 18 November 2026: The Climate Change Committee has now published its letter to the Transport Secretary, Heidi Alexander. It warns that the UK is likely to miss its legal climate targets if the ZEV mandate is weakened, and urges ministers to keep the current 2030 car targets. Details of what the letter says are below.
The Climate Change Committee (CCC) wrote to ministers on Wednesday 18 November setting out how changes to the zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate could affect household budgets and the UK’s net zero commitments, as the Guardian had reported on Monday it would. Under the rules as they stand, 80% of new cars sold in 2030 must be zero emission, rising to 100% in 2035, but Labour is reported to be preparing to lower those figures.
The letter is firmly against a cut, which makes any climbdown considerably harder to defend. The CCC’s chair, Nigel Topping, spent around two decades in roles connected to the automotive sector and has repeatedly urged manufacturers to move faster on electric models.
What the CCC letter says about the ZEV mandate
In its letter to Heidi Alexander, signed by Mr Topping, the committee says its view is that the ZEV mandate “is working effectively”. Weakening it, the CCC argues, would put the government’s climate commitments at risk, miss a chance to cut costs for a typical household by around £800 a year, and leave Britain more dependent on volatile oil markets.
The committee leans heavily on the Department for Transport’s own impact assessment. On the CCC’s reading, cutting the headline targets would raise UK fuel use by the equivalent of up to 15 million barrels of oil a year by 2030, costing more than £1 billion at current prices. The mandate also underpins the largest share of emissions cuts to 2037 in the government’s delivery plan, so the legally binding Sixth Carbon Budget, covering 2033 to 2037, would not be met “without alternative action at the same scale”. The extra emissions in 2030 under the deepest option on the table, a 50% target for cars and 40% for vans, would be equivalent to the savings from around 2.8 million home heat pump installations.
The CCC also rejects the claim that the market cannot keep up. This year’s headline target is 33%, but once flexibilities are counted manufacturers need to reach only around 25%, and electric cars took 32% of sales in October. Even so, the committee notes that Germany and France have overtaken the UK on electric car uptake and that Britain now ranks 22nd in the world for EV sales share.
The letter sets out six recommendations: keep the current headline car targets through to 2030; change how plug-in hybrids are credited so the rules reflect their real-world emissions; tighten the CO2 baseline used for new market entrants; set post-2030 rules that maximise electric-only driving; tackle the barriers holding back electric vans; and bring forward policies to cut the cost of public charging. On vans, the committee accepts the transition has been harder and says manufacturers should be given “enough breathing room in the meantime”. It also stresses that the mandate is shared with the Scottish and Welsh governments and the Northern Ireland Executive, whose own carbon budgets depend on it.
“The market has already evolved, and the UK should be accelerating to keep up, not putting the brakes on,” Mr Topping said in a statement alongside the letter. “British drivers deserve better than a backtrack on such critical policy.”
Carmakers were unmoved. The SMMT’s Mike Hawes accused the committee of ignoring the costs of the targets it was defending, according to the BBC, saying: “The industry cannot subsidise the transition indefinitely, which is why it is unified in seeking change.” A government spokesperson said the consultation would “ensure we are taking a pragmatic and balanced approach to the ZEV transition”, while government sources insisted no decision had yet been made.
What the ZEV mandate requires and why it is under review
The mandate sets a rising share of each manufacturer’s new car and van sales that must produce no tailpipe emissions. For vans, the 2030 requirement currently stands at 70%. The government opened a consultation over the summer on whether the trajectory should change, and that exercise closed on 23 October. According to Fleet News, no date has yet been set for the official response, despite intense speculation that an announcement is close.
Earlier this month, the BBC reported that ministers were planning a “significant” reduction to the 2030 car target, as Business Motoring noted. Officially, the government insists its end goals are unchanged. A spokesperson told the Guardian: “We remain committed to the phase out of all new cars relying solely on petrol and diesel engines by 2030, and to 100% of new car and van sales being zero emission by 2035, and our legally binding net zero targets.”
Carmakers say demand is lagging behind the targets
Manufacturers have lobbied hard for change. They argue that buyers are not yet coming forward in the numbers the targets assume, forcing heavy discounting to keep electric registrations on track. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, told the Guardian that while carmakers were investing billions in zero emission vehicles, demand remained below the required levels.
“Regulation mustn’t undermine UK competitiveness or hold back the transition,” he said, calling for “fundamental change to the targets, backed by ongoing and increased support for consumers, including incentives, affordable charging, and tackling disincentives.”
One expert quoted by the Guardian pointed out that the UK is currently beating its sales target by a clear margin, arguing that this undermines claims of widespread forced discounting. The paper also noted that sales of battery electric cars rose by half last month compared with the same month a year earlier.
Campaigners and fleets push back
Opposition to a cut is coming from several directions. Ami McCarthy, head of politics at Greenpeace UK, said watering down the targets “would be like driving with the handbrake on”, adding that aligning the UK’s goals with the EU’s “would only slow us down”.
The driver group EVA England has written to Cabinet Office minister Louise Haigh urging the government to keep the current trajectory. Its chief executive, Dr Vicky Edmonds, said the mandate “has been critical in creating and maintaining an EV market that is starting to work for the consumer”. The organisation’s own survey found that 93% of electric car owners would recommend their vehicle, but 38% said recent government announcements and policy shifts had dented their confidence. EVA England has also renewed its call for the planned pay-per-mile eVED charge on electric cars to be pushed back to at least 2030.
Perhaps more telling is the position of the Association of Fleet Professionals (AFP), whose members buy a large share of Britain’s new electric cars. The AFP wants the 80% car target for 2030 kept, warning that a downward revision could mean lower investment by manufacturers and charge point operators, higher prices and weaker supply. It does, however, back a deeper, time-limited cut for vans, from 70% to 40%, alongside more support for depot charging and grid upgrades. Its government affairs lead, Dale Eynon, said the electric van market had not developed as quickly as cars because ranges were too short, running costs were often higher and public charging was “patchy”.
The cost-of-living argument
The debate has sharpened as fuel bills have soared this autumn. Analysts and campaigners cited by the Guardian say filling a petrol car can now cost more than £100, while an electric car can be fully charged for under £10. That gap is central to the case that slowing the EV transition would hurt households as well as emissions targets.
There is an industrial dimension too. Most cars built in Britain are exported, and electric car sales are growing strongly in the EU, a major market for UK manufacturers. Supporters of the mandate argue that a strong home market helps British factories compete for that business.
What happens next
With the CCC’s letter now published, all eyes are on when ministers publish their consultation response. For drivers, nothing changes immediately: the mandate governs what manufacturers must sell, not what motorists must buy. But the final shape of the rules will influence the range of electric models on sale, the size of dealer discounts and how quickly charging infrastructure expands over the rest of the decade.
For more news on cars, fuel and the rules of the road, visit our Motoring section, and for wider policy coverage see our UK News pages.































