
Jaguar Land Rover has lost the opening round of its legal battle with Chinese giant BYD over the BYD Ti7, after a Dutch court ordered the British carmaker to destroy files seized from BYD’s offices in the Netherlands, weeks before the Defender-rivalling SUV reaches British customers.
The ruling, handed down by the District Court of The Hague on 11 November, does not decide whether the Ti7 copies the Land Rover Defender. But it is an early setback for JLR, which has made protecting the design of its most successful model a priority as a wave of boxy Chinese off-roaders heads for Europe.
What the Dutch court decided
In August, court-appointed bailiffs acting for JLR seized digital records from BYD’s offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp. JLR had obtained permission for the evidence seizure as part of its case that the Ti7 infringes intellectual property rights linked to the Defender.
BYD objected that the material taken went far beyond what was relevant, describing JLR’s approach as a “fishing expedition”, according to Autocar. Judge H.F.R. van Heemstra largely agreed. In a preliminary ruling in summary proceedings, the court lifted the seizure, finding that JLR did not need the records to argue its EU design rights claim, and that they were not required to work out damages either, because the Ti7 has not yet been sold in the EU, electrive reported.
JLR must arrange for the material to be destroyed within 24 hours of the judgment being formally served. Failure to do so carries a penalty of €50,000 an hour, capped at €500,000, Fleet News reported. The court also rejected JLR’s own claim that BYD had run up €500,000 in penalties for failing to cooperate with the seizure, ruling that BYD had met its obligations, and ordered JLR to pay €25,376.57 towards BYD’s legal costs.
The wider BYD Ti7 copycat case continues
Crucially, the judgment says nothing about whether the Ti7 infringes JLR’s rights. Those questions will be tested in separate proceedings: a claim under EU design law in The Hague, and copyright and unfair imitation claims in Rotterdam. The main case is expected to be heard later this month.
JLR’s chief executive, PB Balaji, made clear the company would not back down. “Our vehicles are getting built on decades of heritage, engineering, excellence and, of course, the capability and the craftsmanship that these cars execute,” he told journalists. “Therefore we will do what it takes to protect them.” He also said the seized files were no longer needed, as BYD has since set out its European sales plans for the Ti7. Autocar reported that Balaji “does not accept the infringement” of JLR’s intellectual property.
Why the Ti7 matters to British buyers
The Ti7 is already a major hit in China, where it is sold under BYD’s Fangchengbao brand and has climbed into the country’s top 10 best-sellers. Its upright stance, square wheel arches, body-coloured panel in the rear side window and blacked-out pillars that give a “floating roof” effect have all drawn comparisons with the Defender.
In the UK, the seven-seat plug-in hybrid is priced from £47,995. That undercuts the equivalent Defender by around £20,000; electrive put the starting price of a seven-seat Defender 110 at £68,465. The Ti7 pairs a 1.5-litre turbocharged petrol engine with electric motors for a combined 300kW, and its 35.6kWh battery provides an electric-only range of up to 74 miles, according to Autocar. Fleet News said the model was due in UK showrooms this month, with customer deliveries starting in January.
For JLR, the stakes are high. The Defender is its strongest performer worldwide, with 28,465 sales in the three months to the end of September, up 16%, Autocar reported. The company is also under financial strain, having posted a £451m loss for its second quarter, including £530m of additional costs linked to restructuring and job cuts.
A mixed record on copycat cases
JLR has fought, and won, this kind of battle before. In 2019 it succeeded in a Chinese court against Jiangling Motor over the Landwind X7, which it argued copied the Range Rover Evoque. But it failed in 2020 to stop Ineos from selling the Grenadier on the grounds that it was too similar to the original Defender, a reminder that a distinctive boxy shape is hard to protect in law.
Other manufacturers have successfully kept lookalikes out of Europe in the past, including BMW against a Chinese SUV it argued was an X5 clone. Whether JLR can join them will depend on how the Dutch courts weigh specific design features rather than the general look of a rugged, square-cut 4×4.
What comes next
For now, BYD can press ahead with its UK launch, and British buyers will soon be able to judge the resemblance for themselves in showrooms. The outcome of the main hearings in The Hague and Rotterdam will determine whether the Ti7 faces restrictions in the EU, and will be closely watched by other Chinese brands with Defender-inspired models in the pipeline.
For more on the companies reshaping Britain’s car market, visit our Motoring section and our Business coverage.




























