
Comment: A House of Lords committee says Britain is underprepared for a cascade of crises and that ministers appear complacent. The government should stop defending its record and adopt the report’s core proposals, starting with a minister whose only job is national resilience.
This is an opinion column. Its view is that the Lords national resilience report published on Monday is the most important document Westminster will produce this week, and that its warnings should be acted on rather than politely received.
The committee does not mince its words. “The world is more turbulent and insecure than it has been for decades,” its chair, Baroness Coussins, said on publication. “Yet in the face of potentially catastrophic risks, the Government appears complacent and the UK is underprepared.” Those lines appear in the committee’s own summary, and they come after months of expert hearings.
Planning for one emergency at a time
The central criticism is about how Britain plans. Existing arrangements, the committee found, too often deal with single emergencies, a power cut here, a cyber-attack there, rather than the cascading failures that are increasingly plausible when one shock triggers the next. The Guardian’s account of the report describes this as the risk of a “polycrisis”, and notes the committee’s warning that artificial intelligence is supercharging the threat from cyber-attacks.
Anyone who lived through recent disruption to everyday digital services will recognise the problem. When something essential fails, it rarely fails alone. Payments, logistics, communications and public services are now woven together so tightly that a weakness in one quickly becomes a crisis in the others.
The uncomfortable details
What makes the report hard to dismiss is its specifics. According to the Guardian, the committee found that about 90% of the world’s 6-APA, the compound on which penicillin-type antibiotics are built, comes from China, and that there is now only one integrated penicillin facility in Europe and none in the UK. One witness warned that reliance on overseas-made basics such as surgical scissors and medical staplers could badly disrupt routine operations if supplies were cut off.
Food is just as concentrated. Almost 95% of UK retail food is supplied by nine companies working from 131 distribution hubs, the report found, so trouble at a handful of firms could ripple across the country. And when it comes to the undersea cables that carry Britain’s data, BT has access to just two repair ships: one French-owned and generally unavailable, the other British but 35 years old.
None of this is the stuff of science fiction. These are ordinary supply chains built for cheapness rather than robustness, and the committee is right to say that years of cost-based procurement have left the country exposed.
Why a dedicated minister matters
The full report‘s headline recommendation is a cabinet minister responsible solely for resilience, backed by a chief resilience officer at permanent secretary level. It also calls for a single national resilience strategy, statutory footing and proper funding for local resilience forums, proportionate preparedness duties on businesses essential to national life, and wider cyber security regulation.
Sceptics will say that another minister is just another title. They are wrong. Resilience is the classic Whitehall orphan: everybody’s business and therefore nobody’s priority. Today the Cabinet Office leads on resilience among many other competing duties. A named secretary of state, answerable to Parliament, would give the subject a champion at the table when budgets are set, and someone to blame when plans are not tested. The committee’s suggestion of an annual statement to Parliament by the prime minister on the state of preparedness would add a useful moment of public accountability.
Trust the public with the truth
The most welcome part of the report is its faith in ordinary people. It urges ministers to build on the “Be Ready” campaign by sending every household a preparedness booklet, as Denmark and Sweden do, developing a multilingual emergency app and keeping digital terrestrial television running as a backup channel rather than switching it off. Baroness Coussins told the Guardian that the evidence shows the public would be “reassured, not alarmed” by candid information.
She is right. British households have shown repeatedly that they will rise to an emergency if they are told plainly what to do. Treating them as too fragile to hear about risks to medicine, food or communications is not caution; it is condescension.
The Cabinet Office says it will “carefully review” the recommendations and points to its awareness campaign, a large home defence exercise planned for next year and more than £1bn invested in pandemic security. That is a respectable start, and ministers deserve credit for moving at all. But the committee has asked for a national resilience strategy within six months. The government should accept that deadline, appoint the minister and publish the plan. The next crisis will not wait for a review.
Read more on how one technology outage exposed Britain’s dependence on a single supplier, and find more comment in our opinion section.





























