
Burnham’s rejection of Welsh devolution requests has opened a rift with Cardiff: in a letter dated 20 November 2026, the prime minister told First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth he was “not persuaded” to devolve policing, justice, the Crown Estate or rail infrastructure to Wales, a decision that also puts him at odds with Welsh Labour.
The letter, seen by BBC Wales, landed days after Andy Burnham told Welsh Labour’s conference in Llandudno that communities should have “real power over the decisions that shape their lives”, according to Nation.Cymru. The Welsh Government says it shows Wales is not treated as an equal nation. Ministers in London say devolution should be about more than moving powers between governments.
What did Burnham’s letter to Wales say?
On policing, Burnham said the integrated England and Wales system is “essential to maintaining interoperability”, allowing cross-border working and letting Welsh forces draw on national and specialist capabilities. On justice, he said the shared system gives Wales access to the “resources, expertise and resilience” of a bigger network.
On the Crown Estate, which includes the seabed off the Welsh coast, he said the government was “not persuaded by the case for devolving the management of the Crown Estate in Wales, nor to prepare for a future transfer”. Its current model, he argued, is the best way to maximise benefits for Wales. On rail, he said funding and delivery are best handled by the new Great British Railways working with Transport for Wales and the Welsh Government, because full devolution would fragment a highly integrated cross-border network.
Why is the Welsh Government so angry?
Rhun ap Iorwerth told BBC Radio Wales he was “pretty gobsmacked”, saying the decision was Westminster saying “we decide, it doesn’t matter what the people of Wales think”. He told Radio 4’s Today programme that Burnham had more influence over policing as mayor of Greater Manchester than he has as first minister.
A spokesperson for the first minister said Burnham’s “warm words on devolution are now ringing hollow” and that his talk of driving power out of Whitehall appeared to mean only the English regions. The Welsh Government listed all four areas as immediate priorities in a written answer to the Senedd on 11 November, and Mr ap Iorwerth has called for powers equal to Scotland’s, where the Crown Estate was devolved in 2017.
A problem inside the Labour family
The decision is awkward for Burnham because Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates said at the party’s conference that devolving policing and the Crown Estate remained party policy. Welsh Liberal Democrat leader David Chadwick said the prime minister “owes Wales an explanation”, while the pro-independence group YesCymru said all 22 Welsh councils and the Senedd had backed devolving the Crown Estate.
The tone also contrasts with a more positive reading of the Glasgow talks last month. Mr ap Iorwerth said then that he thought the prime minister “instinctively” wanted to move on policing, and Burnham had earlier said he was “open” to the idea, the BBC reported. Burnham’s letter, however, is clear that he is not.
What is on offer instead?
Welsh Secretary Stephen Kinnock said the prime minister had set out “an offer” to work in partnership on growth and jobs, reindustrialisation and empowering Welsh communities. He said the offer covered devolving fiscal powers, employment support, innovation and regional empowerment, and that devolution “must be about more than transferring powers from one government to another”. Kinnock said that changing the powers in question risked “destabilisation and fragmentation and disintegration”. His line: “What matters is what works.”
That points to a model where Cardiff and local partners get more say over economic levers, while core institutions stay shared. Whether that satisfies a Plaid Cymru-led government is another matter. For more on the prime minister’s wider agenda, see our Politics coverage.
What happens next?
For Welsh readers, nothing changes immediately: police, courts, the Crown Estate’s Welsh revenues and rail infrastructure all stay as they are, with no transfer planned. The practical changes to watch are the talks on fiscal powers, employment support and innovation funding that both governments say they want to continue.
Politically the row may run longer. Burnham has leaned heavily on devolution as a theme, and a refusal in Cardiff sits uneasily beside it. It arrives in the same week he agreed a UK-EU youth mobility scheme in Brussels, and as the government faces the question of EU tuition fees. Expect Plaid Cymru and YesCymru to keep pressing the “equal nation” argument, and Welsh Labour to face questions over whether its own policy can survive contact with Downing Street. Read the full BBC Wales report or Nation.Cymru’s account.


































