
Jilly Cooper plagiarism claims have resurfaced more than a year after the novelist’s death, after an Observer investigation published on 22 November 2026 alleged that her 1978 romance Prudence borrows heavily from two earlier novels: The Serial by the American writer Cyra McFadden and The Franchise Affair by Josephine Tey. The daughter of McFadden says she is now considering legal options.
Key points
- An Observer investigation published on 22 November 2026 alleges that Jilly Cooper’s 1978 novel Prudence contains 35 separate passages echoing Cyra McFadden’s 1977 novel The Serial.
- The Observer also alleges that Prudence lifts a courtroom scene from chapter 22 of Josephine Tey’s 1948 detective novel The Franchise Affair.
- Caroline McFadden, the daughter of Cyra McFadden, said she would be “looking at legal options”.
- Penguin, Cooper’s publisher, and her agent Felicity Blunt at Curtis Brown declined to respond to the findings, according to the Observer.
What is Jilly Cooper accused of?
Jilly Cooper, who died in October 2025, is accused of copying dialogue and narrative structure from two other writers into Prudence, the fifth of her 1970s romances. The newspaper says that almost every line spoken by Berenice, an American feminist character, echoes lines from The Serial, with in some passages only the names changed.
The Observer’s investigation, by the critic Kate Maltby, sets out 15 side-by-side comparisons. The newspaper said the textual comparisons were carried out by hand rather than with artificial intelligence software, and that it began looking at the book after a reader noticed similarities with a scene by Tey.
The Observer notes that it has not been confirmed that Cooper infringed copyright.
Prudence and The Serial: how close are the passages?
The closest passages in Prudence and The Serial differ by only a handful of words. The Serial, a satire of the self-help language of California’s Marin County, was first serialised in the US newspaper the Pacific Sun from late 1975 and came out as a book in May 1977, ten months before Prudence was published in the UK.
A selection of the lines the Observer published side by side shows the pattern:
| Prudence (Jilly Cooper, 1978) | Earlier novel |
|---|---|
| “I wanted an open living relationship based on trust and growth, and all he wanted was his jockey shorts ironed.” | “I wanted an open, loving relationship, based on growth and trust and sharing, and Harvey wanted his jockey shorts ironed.” (The Serial) |
| “It’s hard to keep your mind alive when you spend your time with people three feet high.” | “It was hard to keep your mind alive when you spent most of your time with people three feet high.” (The Serial) |
| “Against my will, my eyes went to Ricky Wetherby and came away at once. It was crucifixion.” | “Against my will, my eyes went to Mrs Wynn, and came away at once. It was crucifixion.” (The Franchise Affair) |
Cooper did know McFadden’s book. In a 1982 Mail on Sunday column, quoted by the Observer, she described The Serial as “a marvellously funny send-up of American trendies in the late seventies”, but she did not acknowledge it in published editions of Prudence.
The novelist and biographer DJ Taylor, who has written widely on plagiarism, told the Observer that Cooper appeared to have “driven a coach-and-four through the barrier that separates research and straightforward expropriation”.
What has Cyra McFadden’s family said?
Caroline McFadden, whose mother died in 2024, said she was angry and was weighing legal action. “To steal her work so extensively and to profit off it is unconscionable,” she told the Observer. “I will be looking at legal options as this can’t be allowed to stand.”
She added that she hoped all of Cooper’s work would be “scrutinised to see if this was a pattern”. Josephine Tey, the pen name of Elizabeth MacKintosh, died in 1952 and left no heirs, the Observer said.
The question of any claim is not simple. Under UK rules, copyright in a written work usually lasts 70 years after the author’s death, which means Tey’s novels are likely to be out of copyright here, while McFadden’s work remains protected. The Guardian said it had also contacted Penguin and Curtis Brown for comment.
Background: has Jilly Cooper faced plagiarism claims before?
Jilly Cooper has faced plagiarism claims before, though none as extensive. In 1976 the writer Auberon Waugh pointed to “an amazing similarity” between passages in her first novel, Emily, and Georgette Heyer’s Devil’s Cub. In 1986 Private Eye compared short passages in Emily and Bella with Elaine Dundy’s 1958 novel The Dud Avocado.
Seven years later Cooper admitted the overlap with Dundy’s book was “embarrassing” but said it “can happen to any writer”, blaming a mix-up of notes she had taken while reading it. The Observer argues that its new findings cannot be explained that way.
The claims matter because of Cooper’s standing. She sold more than 11 million books in the UK alone, was made a dame in the 2024 new year honours for services to literature and charity, and drew public tributes from Queen Camilla on her death on 5 October 2025, after a fall at her Gloucestershire home.
What it means for Rivals fans and readers
For readers and viewers, nothing changes immediately: the claims concern Prudence, an early romance, not Rivals or the other Rutshire Chronicles. Disney+ is screening the second series of Rivals, and the Observer reports that the first half of that series became the platform’s most-watched show in the UK and Northern Ireland when it was released in May.
The real pressure is on Cooper’s estate and publisher. The Observer says it asked Penguin and Curtis Brown to carry out a full audit of her work. Any wider check of her books using AI tools would probably need the estate to give copyright permission, the newspaper added. Whether Penguin agrees, and whether the McFadden family goes to court, will decide whether the story goes beyond a literary row.
More publishing news is in our Books section, with screen news in Entertainment.


































